The Former Scottish First Minister said that trans individuals are being used as a “battering ram” in politics
BY KAY TRAYFORD, IMAGE BY FLICKR
Speaking at the Charleston Literary Festival on 19 May, Former Scottish First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, stated that she received backlash and encountered hostility over her government’s proposed trans law reforms and that this played a significant role in her decision to resign.
Reported by the Daily Telegraph via Politico, Sturgeon said: “I’ve had more abuse hurled at me over the issue of trans rights than probably any other issue I’ve discussed, including Scottish independence probably, so it has been really, really difficult.”
She further expressed concern that trans individuals are being increasingly targeted in political conflicts, describing them as being used as a “battering ram”.
The proposed gender recognition reforms in Scotland sought to simplify the legal process for individuals seeking to change their gender. Key elements of the proposal included lowering the age requirement from 18 to 16 as well as eliminating the need for a gender dysphoria diagnosis. However, these reforms faced substantial opposition and were eventually blocked by the UK government, which argued that the bill encroached on reserved powers.
Reflecting on the severe criticism she endured, Sturgeon hoped her resignation might lead to more constructive political discourse in Scotland. “Maybe the politics, the discourse and the debate in Scotland will be a bit more healthy,” she reflected, acknowledging that this has not yet been the case.
Of course, Sturgeon’s leadership was also marked by other significant challenges including difficulties in advancing a second independence referendum, a public fallout with her predecessor Alex Salmond, and let us never forget, a police investigation into SNP fundraising practices. Sturgeon herself was questioned during this investigation, and her husband, former SNP Chief Executive Peter Murrell, faced charges.
Additionally, the introduction of the Hate Crime And Public Order (Scotland) Act in April has stirred controversy. The act criminalises “stirring up hatred” based on characteristics such as age, disability, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity and variations in sex characteristics.
Critics, including J.K. Rowling, have expressed concerns over the implications of the new law. The Harry Potter author has even said that “[She] look[s] forward to being arrested”.
Trans individuals worldwide face significant challenges amid debates over their rights. Reforms to the Gender Recognition Act aimed to simplify legal gender changes but were blocked by the UK government, polarising political and social discourse. Public figures like Nicola Sturgeon have faced backlash over their stances, hindering constructive dialogue and progress. Scotland’s Hate Crime And Public Order Act, which protects trans identities, has also drawn mixed reactions, highlighting the struggle to balance free speech and anti-discrimination efforts, and underscoring the need for inclusive policymaking.
DIVA magazine celebrates 30 years in print in 2024. If you like what we do, then get behind LGBTQIA media and keep us going for another generation. Your support is invaluable.
