Sandra Hüller stars in this new film about a mysterious soldier

BY KAITLIN WILLOUGHBY, IMAGE BY SCHUBERT, ROW PICTURES, WALKER+WORM FILM, GERALD KERKLETZ

For a long time queer stories have been written out of history. But this year has been a spectacle for LGBTQIA+ period pieces like La Bola Negra. Joining the ensemble of award-winning titles emerging from the global film festival circuit is Markus Schleinzer’s Rose – opening the MUBI Film Festival at Hackney Picturehouse(13 November). 

Sandra Hüller plays Rose, a woman who disguises herself as a male soldier. When she shows up to a rural village to claim land, the villagers are suspicious of her but soon grow to respect her. But when she’s forced to marry, her life unravels. 

In this 17th-century village, villagers are governed harshly by Christian doctrine and patriarchy. The themes of suspicion, devout faith and the tempestuous weather give the film a folklore-like quality. Everyone is living within the bounds of religion, patriarchal expectations and societal norms. 

Director Markus Schleinzer told the MUBI Film Festival audience that he found many similar stories whilst researching, usually motivated by ambitions of freedom from the shackles of sex-based discrimination. The film doesn’t fully engage with either Rose’s gender identity or her sexuality – a decision that Schleinzer described as “conscious” – as he did not want to focus on why Rose chooses to wear trousers, but instead on the response. 

This is a bleak, hopeless film that mirrors the bleak state of gender discrimination and patriarchy today. Importantly, it is also a film which mirrors the absurdities of the “gender critical” debate.

It is harrowing to think that the villagers, who demand proof of Rose’s gender by asking her to drop her trousers, have a mindset that is reflected in current social discourse around the trans community. None of Rose’s contributions, from her past as a soldier to her effort in the community, stand up against her “deceit”. 

It harks back to the idea of gender as conformity, something we owe to others rather than ourselves. Schleinzer encourages viewers to radically question identity, in lines such as ‘‘we all imagined ourselves”. 

This is not explicitly a sapphic film. There is no real romance in Rose’s relationship. However, the camaraderie they share in the face of the threat of the outside world was a beacon of hope in an otherwise morose film. Both women want the freedom to live their lives, and both pay the ultimate price for their audacity.  

Rose comes to UK cinemas on 5 February 2027. 

Love media made by and for LGBTQIA+ women and gender diverse people? Then you’ll love DIVA. We’ve been spotlighting the community for over 30 years. Here’s how you can get behind queer media and keep us going for another generation: linkin.bio/ig-divamagazine 

Did you know that DIVA has now become a charity? Our magazine is published by the DIVA Charitable Trust. You can find out more about the organisation and how you can offer your support here: divacharitabletrust.com

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.