“As ever with discrimination, anti-trans narratives affect marginalised groups the most”
BY GEORGIE BULL, IMAGE BY GETTY IMAGES
Welcome to Queer Election Watch, a collaboration between DIVA, QueerAF and Trans+ History Week. We’re here to help you cut through the noise and make sense of the issues that really matter to you, so that you can make a more informed vote in the upcoming general election.
Normally, journalists would think twice about creating any form of threat towards clients of a rape crisis centre while they’re trying to access help, so what was the cause of the heartless oversight? It was an opportunity to get “Trans” in a headline.
The Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre recently lost an employment tribunal for their “flawed” disciplinary process of an employee who expressed gender-critical beliefs. Though these beliefs are protected in UK law, they are widely condemned as an extremist anti-rights movement, and actions leading from these beliefs aren’t necessarily protected.
As a transgender survivor of sexual violence, Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre’s actions signalled that they are a safe place to seek help (which is not guaranteed in the UK), and they are. They are excellent.
After the tribunal ruling, however, I received a message informing me that their building was being subject to “press attention” and asking if I wanted to cancel my appointment. The illusion of safety was shattered. These appointments are supposed to be a place of privacy, safety and healing. Journalists waiting outside, unknown to vulnerable and traumatised service users of the centre, delivers none of that.
This threat of more harassment, potential press attention and even being captured on camera, caused me to have two panic attacks in the run-up to my appointment.
When I arrived at the Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre, shaking but ready for the interview, there were thankfully no journalists there. The relief I felt was quickly subsumed by the usual fear and anger. Whilst attending the centre though, I did learn that “bigoted” and “hostile” journalists had spent time outside the building as the story was in the headlines. That action robbed me – and I’m sure many other service users – of dignity and privacy. I struggle to see how it can be justified.
There has been an explosion of articles on trans people in the British press over the last few years. It is seen as a “hot topic”, a culture war issue guaranteed to grab the reader’s attention and satisfy the demand for content.
You can get used to anything. Hate crime, abuse, and assault is an everyday fear for me now. Fuelled by an abusive media frenzy over our existence, violence against trans people rises year on year and sits at a record high.
I am used to the deluge of messages telling us that our bodies are criminal and our existence is a threat, but I never expected direct media harassment of sexual assault survivors. I should have known better.
Meanwhile something that gets all too lost is that transphobia harms everyone. It only takes a look at the rapidly increasing number of cisgender women being denied access to “single-sex” spaces and it’s easy to realise that the policing of women’s bodies and behaviours hurts all of us.
It shouldn’t take US laws mandating genital inspections of children suspected of being trans, for us to see that this isn’t about protecting anyone.
As ever with discrimination, anti-trans narratives affect marginalised groups the most.
This alongside growing evidence that transphobia and white supremacist views are intrinsically linked. Cis and trans women alike are harassed, attacked, and murdered for not conforming to stereotypes of how a woman should look and behave, and this violence disproportionately affects people of colour.
To quote writer and lawyer Olayemi Olurin: “Transphobia is not a trans problem, it’s all of ours.”
In an election cycle with such a transphobic focus, this fact is often overlooked by those kicking around the ‘political football’ of our human rights.
Rampant transphobia is peddled as fair political “debate”. Gender critical extremists have entrenched a rhetoric that major political powers now dance to.
It is utterly disingenuous, as many politicians and gender critical activists have, to frame this agenda as “protecting women and girls”, to – in the name of women’s rights – harass rape survivors who have nowhere else to go.
Meanwhile, so much of the UK media is peddling and normalising this kind of hate where clicks trump reason or humanity.
In the run up to this election, it is more important now than ever that we see this scapegoating for what it is.
Stay tuned to Queer Election Watch for more on the issues that matter to you. Wondering how to place your vote in the upcoming general election? Here’s everything you need to know about making your voice heard on voting day.
DIVA magazine celebrates 30 years in print in 2024. If you like what we do, then get behind LGBTQIA media and keep us going for another generation. Your support is invaluable.
